Hi Amanda, thanks for posting in the Microsoft community, even though you enabled auditing in Local Group Policy, Windows doesn't retroactively log events. It only starts logging after the policy is applied and the system is restarted, here’s what you can do.
First, Confirm Audit Policy is Active, Open Command Prompt as Admin then Run: auditpol /get /category:Logon/Logoff then make sure Logon, Logoff, and Other Logon/Logoff Events show as Success or Success and Failure.
Next, Restart Your PC, if you haven’t since enabled the policy, then Wait for New Events to be generated, only events after the restart will show up.
Also, Check Event Viewer Again, simply Go to your custom view then make sure the date filter is correct and not too narrow.
I hope this helps you out, let me know how it goes.
Chard